Gordon B. Coyle, CPCU, President of The Coyle Group commercial insurance brokerage in New City, NY
Leadership Profile

Gordon B. Coyle

CPCU · ARM · AMIM · PWCA

Four decades inside commercial insurance, and a family name in the business since 1929.

Chief Visionary Officer & President · The Coyle Group

40+years in commercial insurance
1929family in insurance since
$10M–500M+client revenue range
600+educational videos

Who is Gordon Coyle?

Gordon B. Coyle is the President of The Coyle Group, an independent commercial insurance broker based in New City, New York, that places coverage for mid-market companies across the United States. He has more than 40 years of experience working with business owners and specializes in complex commercial insurance structures and placements. He has deep domain expertise in management and professional liability, ocean cargo, workers’ compensation, complex property risks, cyber, and product liability insurance.

Gordon works with companies doing $10M to $500M+ in revenue, most often in manufacturing, wholesale distribution, international trade, technology, financial services and construction. He has personally advised hundreds of business owners nationwide on complex insurance programs.

Industries Gordon serves
  • Manufacturing
  • Wholesale distribution
  • International trade
  • Technology
  • Financial services
  • Construction
Outside the office

Gordon enjoys time outdoors hiking, backpacking, climbing and adventuring, as well as working out, reading and spending time with his family.

In Gordon’s words

I’ve spent 40+ years watching the insurance industry change, and not always for the better.

“I continue to be amazed at how poorly many commercial insurance accounts are written, managed and renewed. … Fixing these problems usually isn’t expensive or difficult, but it does take expertise to find them.”

Gordon B. Coyle, President, The Coyle Group
From “9 out of 10 Business Insurance Policies Have Fatal Flaws”

Areas of practice

What Gordon focuses on

Five areas of practice, each built on a formal designation or decades of placement work.

01

Executive liability

D&O · EPL · Fiduciary

Gordon helps leadership teams and boards protect their personal assets when decisions get challenged. “Where many insureds run into trouble is that they are served a summons or some other qualifying notice that would be a claim under the policy, and they ignore it… Then the claim heats up three or four months later, and then they decide to report it. That’s when a claim can be denied for late notice.”

02

Cyber liability & technology risk

Cyber · Technology

“In my opinion, the most important thing a cyber policy does is provide you an emergency hotline when something bad happens.”

03

Workers’ compensation strategy

PWCA · Mods · Claims

As a Professional Workers’ Compensation Advisor, Gordon looks past the premium: experience mods, classification codes and claims handling. “I have studied workers comp extensively because I believe it to be the most controllable line of insurance there is… My focus here has paid big dividends for my clients.”

04

Marine & international insurance

AMIM · Cargo · Trade

His Associate in Marine Insurance Management designation backs his work with importers, distributors and companies moving goods internationally.

05

Complex programs & claims advocacy

Multi-line · Captives · M&A

“If your company has a history of low claims in your business insurance program, right now you’re returning significant profits to the insurance company.” And when a claim hits: “We’re in your corner to advocate on your behalf.”

Already have a broker? Get a second opinion.

Many of Gordon’s clients come to him for a fresh look at a program that hasn’t kept up with the business.

Request a review →
The letters after the name

Designations, explained

Four professional designations, and what each one means for the companies Gordon advises.

CPCU
Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter

Advanced training in property and casualty insurance, risk and policy language.

ARM
Associate in Risk Management

Trained to identify, measure and reduce business risk, not just insure it.

AMIM
Associate in Marine Insurance Management

Specialized knowledge of cargo, ocean marine and international trade coverage.

PWCA
Professional Workers’ Compensation Advisor

Focused training in controlling workers’ comp costs and claims.

On the record

Results Gordon has led

Financial services / M&A firm
$2M+

In coverage gaps found.

Ocean cargo client
$10–12K

In dividends recovered through a profit-sharing clause.

Food distributor
$6–7M

In property underinsurance identified.

On YouTube

Learn from Gordon

Practical insurance advice from The Coyle Group’s library of 600+ educational videos.

The interview

Questions people ask Gordon

Answers in his own words, on the questions buyers bring to every first conversation.

What’s the biggest mistake you see mid-market companies make with their insurance?

“The bottom line is that almost all insurance programs we review contain at least one fatal mistake. Often due to complacency, a lack of attention to details, poor communication, or plainly just a lack of expertise… We recently worked with a manufacturer who had been with the same broker for 14 or 15 years. Their business income coverage was undercalculated by 50% and they had no cyber protection.”

When should a company consider switching brokers?

“Maybe the service is mediocre. Maybe your premiums are sky-high. Or maybe you just have a hunch that something isn’t right.”

What does a CPCU designation mean for my business?

The Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter is one of the most demanding designations in property and casualty insurance. In Gordon’s words: “I got these designations and became a student of insurance.”

Does Gordon work with companies outside New York?

Yes. “We serve businesses across the United States and globally.”

Free · 30 minutes

Work with Gordon.

If your business is doing $10M to $500M+ in revenue and you’re not sure your coverage fits how you operate today, Gordon and the team offer a free 30-minute Insurance Confidence Assessment.

Book your assessment →

← Meet the rest of The Coyle Group team