Caitlin E. Puckett, Account Manager at The Coyle Group commercial insurance brokerage
Team Profile

Caitlin E. Puckett

LICENSED IN MISSISSIPPI

10 years helping contractors and trucking companies stay fully insured, priced right and supported when a claim happens.

Account Manager · The Coyle Group

10Years in commercial insurance
6Years in core commercial lines
5Years insuring contractors and trucking
6Age she started singing

Who is Caitlin Puckett?

Caitlin E. Puckett is an Account Manager at The Coyle Group, an independent commercial insurance broker based in New City, New York. She has 10 years of commercial insurance experience and specializes in construction and contractors insurance (5 years) and trucking insurance (5 years).

Caitlin focuses on pricing adjustments, coverage reviews that make sure clients are fully insured for their needs, and claims support that keeps the process running smoothly. Before joining The Coyle Group in 2026, she was a Commercial Lines Account Manager at Renasant/Sunstar Insurance and an Agent at State Farm Insurance.

Industries Caitlin serves
  • Construction & contractors
  • Trucking
Carriers Caitlin works with
  • AIG
  • Chubb
  • The Hartford
  • Travelers
  • Liberty Mutual
Outside the office

Caitlin loves being outdoors with her dogs and spending time with her family. She has been singing since she was 6 years old.

Why Caitlin chose insurance

I’m a people person and love helping others, and this is a great industry to be in for that.

Caitlin E. Puckett, Account Manager, The Coyle Group

Areas of practice

What Caitlin focuses on

Five areas built on a decade of commercial lines account management.

01

Construction & contractors

Contractors · 5 years

Five years managing insurance programs for construction companies and contractors.

02

Trucking & commercial auto

Trucking · Auto · Fleets

Five years insuring trucking companies and six years in commercial auto, including fleet management.

03

Core commercial lines

GL · Property · Workers’ comp

Six years each in general liability, commercial property and workers’ compensation.

04

Coverage reviews & pricing

Pricing · Coverage fit

Caitlin makes pricing adjustments as needed and makes sure clients are fully insured based on their needs.

05

Claims support

Claims · Advocacy

She helps clients through claims so the process goes smoothly, including advocacy and negotiation with carriers.

Already have a broker? Get a second opinion.

A fresh look at a program that hasn’t kept up with your business.

Request a review →
Good to know

Questions about Caitlin

What kinds of businesses does Caitlin work with?

Construction companies and contractors (5 years) and trucking companies (5 years).

What coverages does Caitlin handle most?

General liability, commercial auto, workers’ compensation and commercial property, with six years of experience in each.

How does Caitlin help with claims?

She helps clients through the claims process so it goes smoothly, including advocacy and negotiation with carriers.

Free · 30 minutes

Work with Caitlin.

Not sure your coverage fits how your business operates today? Caitlin and the team offer a free 30-minute Insurance Confidence Assessment.

Book your assessment →

← Meet the rest of The Coyle Group team