Michael R. Vanderwerker, Chief Integration Officer of The Coyle Group commercial insurance brokerage
Leadership Profile

Michael R. Vanderwerker

LICENSED P&C · LIFE, ACCIDENT & HEALTH BROKER

41 years designing layered insurance programs and closing the coverage gaps others miss.

Chief Integration Officer · The Coyle Group

41Years in the insurance industry
99%Year-over-year retention on a benefits program he built
20Carriers he works with regularly
3Olympic Trials as a professional cyclist

Who is Mike Vanderwerker?

Michael R. “Mike” Vanderwerker is the Chief Integration Officer of The Coyle Group, an independent commercial insurance broker based in New City, New York. He has 41 years in the insurance industry and specializes in designing layered insurance programs that integrate multiple carriers to optimize coverage, cost efficiency and risk management for clients with complex exposures.

Before joining The Coyle Group in 2026, Mike served as CEO of MHB Insurance, Vice President of Commercial Lines at AssuredPartners and an Account Executive at HUB International. His deepest experience is in general liability, commercial property and workers’ compensation (40 years each), commercial excess and umbrella (38 years), directors and officers liability (35 years), public officials liability (25 years) and cyber liability (15 years).

Industries Mike serves
  • Manufacturing
  • Publishers
  • Non-profits
  • Technology
  • Municipalities
  • Fire companies
  • Microbreweries
Carriers Mike works with
  • Travelers
  • The Hartford
  • Chubb
  • Hanover
  • Selective
  • Merchants Mutual
  • Guard
  • PERMA
  • Philadelphia Insurance
  • EMC
  • UFG
  • Acuity
  • AIG
  • ACE
  • Great American
  • HCC
  • Tokio Marine
  • Liberty Mutual
  • Nationwide
  • Cincinnati Insurance
Outside the office

Mike was a professional cyclist. He competed in three Olympic Trials and numerous national and New York State championships, winning 12 state championship medals.

In Mike’s words

I really enjoy working with clients and helping them solve their insurance issues. It gives me a sense of satisfaction when I know I’ve helped them protect their assets to the best of my ability.

Michael R. Vanderwerker, Chief Integration Officer, The Coyle Group

Areas of practice

What Mike focuses on

Five areas built on four decades of commercial placements, from single-carrier policies to complex layered programs.

01

Layered, multi-carrier programs

Excess · Umbrella · Multi-state

Mike designs and implements layered insurance programs that integrate multiple carriers to optimize coverage and cost efficiency for clients with complex exposures.

02

Self-insured programs & claims advocacy

SIR · TPA · Claims

He builds self-insured and partially self-insured retention programs, and advocates on claims alongside third-party administrators and in-house or contracted counsel.

03

Workplace violence prevention

OSHA · PESH · Training
  • Risk assessments and gap analyses
  • Policies, procedures and reporting protocols
  • Manager and staff training, including tabletop exercises
  • Incident response and corrective action plans
  • Documentation aligned to OSHA and PESH requirements
04

Management & cyber liability

D&O · Public officials · Cyber

35 years placing directors and officers coverage, 25 years in public officials liability for municipalities and fire companies, and 15 years in cyber liability.

05

Core commercial lines

GL · Property · Workers’ comp · Fleet

Four decades of general liability, commercial property and workers’ compensation, including experience mod management, commercial auto fleets and multi-state programs.

Gaps in your current program? Get a second opinion.

Closing coverage gaps in existing programs is one of the problems Mike solves most often.

Request a review →
On the record
99%

Year-over-year retention

A voluntary benefits program, built from scratch

Mike developed a voluntary payroll-deduct benefits program that combined auto, homeowners and other personal lines insurance using specialized multi-carrier software. It let employers offer multiple products through a single payroll slot, achieved 99% retention year over year and created an additional revenue stream from commercial clients.

The interview

Questions people ask Mike

What is a layered insurance program?

A layered program integrates multiple carriers, each taking part of the risk, to optimize coverage, cost efficiency and risk management for businesses with complex exposures. Mike specializes in designing and implementing them.

What kinds of organizations does Mike work with?

Manufacturers, publishers and non-profits (38 years each), technology companies (30 years), municipalities and fire companies (25 years each) and microbreweries (15 years).

Does Mike help with workplace violence prevention?

Yes. He conducts risk assessments, drafts policies and reporting protocols, designs training and tabletop exercises, sets up incident response plans and aligns documentation to OSHA and PESH requirements for audit readiness.

Can Mike advocate on claims for self-insured programs?

Yes. Claims advocacy and negotiation are a core skill, particularly for self-insured and partially self-insured programs that use a third-party administrator and in-house or contracted counsel.

Free · 30 minutes

Work with Mike.

If your business is doing $10M to $500M+ in revenue and you’re not sure your coverage fits how you operate today, Mike and the team offer a free 30-minute Insurance Confidence Assessment.

Book your assessment →

← Meet the rest of The Coyle Group team