Financial Service Firm Insurance

Protecting Your Business From Costly Risks

Home » Insurance By Industry » Financial Service Firm Insurance

How To Get The Best Insurance For Financial Service Firms

Let’s Chat

Index

Gordon B. Coyle

CEO, The Coyle Group
845-474-2924

How to get started

  • Book a free 30-minute call with our insurance expert.
  • Get your tailored Financial Firm Insurance quote.
  • We handle the transition and ensure zero coverage gaps.
Book a Call and get covered!

Executive Summary(TL;DR)

  • Not standard business insurance. Financial firms need tailored policies that go beyond slip-and-fall or property coverage, and that’s why having Financial Services Insurance built specifically for these exposures is critical.
  • Coordinated protection. Programs combine E&O, D&O, Crime/Fidelity Bonds, and Cyber into one portfolio to safeguard the firm, leadership, and client assets.
  • Unique exposures. SEC, FINRA, and state oversight, client trust obligations, and cybercrime risks create liabilities that generic programs miss.
  • Critical endorsements matter. Social engineering/funds transfer fraud, client funds coverage, and regulatory investigation defense are often excluded unless added.
  • Claims are real. Wire-transfer fraud, board-level lawsuits, and employee dishonesty are among the most common, costly events in the sector.
  • Cost drivers differ. Revenue, AUM, claims history, and compliance posture weigh more heavily than office size or location.
  • Why work with The Coyle Group. With 95+ years as a family-founded brokerage and Gordon Coyle’s 40+ years of expertise, The Coyle Group blends tradition with innovation to deliver the protection financial firms need most.

Bottom line

Getting this right requires a broker who specializes in financial institutions, not a generalist placing office packages.

Talk to a specialized broker

And protect your financial service firm

What Is Financial Services Insurance?

Definition & Core Purpose

Financial Services Insurance is a specialized portfolio of policies designed for Private Equity, Venture Capital, Hedge Funds, Private Investment Funds, banks, credit unions, RIAs, broker-dealers, Hard Money Lenders, and Fintech/Payment Platforms.

The portfolio of policies coordinates professional/management liability, crime insurance, and cyber with traditional Property & Casualty policies to protect the firm, leadership, and balance sheet against regulatory, client, and operational exposures unique to finance.

How Does Financial Service Firm Insurance Differ From Standard Business Insurance

Generic business programs focus on premises injuries, property damage, and basic cyber/data protection. Financial services require sector-specific forms and endorsements, for example:

Asset Managers Policy (AMP)

AMP combines E&O and D&O insurance coverages into one policy

  • E&O or Professional Liabilityis intended to protect the firm and its employees from claims tied to mistakes, errors, or omissions in providing investment advice, trade execution errors, or failure to follow mandates, as well as negligence in professional services.
  • D&O Coverage protects the firm and its leadership team from claims alleging mismanagement, breach of duty, or poor decisions that harm investors, clients, or the firm itself.

Crime/Fidelity Bonds

Crime/Fidelity Bonds are mandated for broker-dealers under FINRA Rule 4360 (employee dishonesty, forgery, securities fraud), with options for social engineering/FTF that are often not included by default.

Cyber Insurance

Cyber Insurancethat addresses Business Email Compromise/wire-transfer fraud and regulatory notification, often via specific endorsements or paired crime coverage to close gaps.

This coordination matters. Many losses in finance originate within the workflow (employee action, payment instructions, third-party tech), where coverage can hinge on definitions and exclusions, not just limits.

Why Financial Services Firms Need Specialized Coverage

Unique Risks in the Financial Services Sector

Financial Service firms operate in one of the most heavily regulated and high-stakes environments. Unlike manufacturers or retailers, your exposures are rooted in trust, client assets, and complex regulatory oversight. A single misstep can triggerlawsuits, investigations, or financial crime losses.

Two financial professionals reviewing portfolio performance on a tablet in a high-rise office, illustrating the risk-analysis side of financial services insurance.
  • Regulatory scrutiny: SEC, FINRA, state regulators, and industry-specific oversight (e.g., CFPB for lenders) create continuous liability pressure.
  • Cyber dependency: Online trading platforms, client portals, and mobile apps are prime targets for hackers. Business email compromise (BEC) and funds-transfer fraud hit financial firms disproportionately.
  • Third-party reliance: Custodians, fintech platforms, and payment processors create interconnected risks; if they fail, your clients look to you.
  • Reputation risk: Trust is everything. Even one claim, paid or not, can spark client flight, reputational damage, and lost assets under management.

In short, standard insurance is not enough. Specialized programs are built around your regulatory environment, asset-handling role, and cyber-crime exposures.

Book a Call with an expert who understands your risks

Real-World Claim Examples

1

Wire Transfer Fraud (Wealth Manager)

A mid-sized RIA fell victim to a business email compromise. Hackers mimicked a client email, requesting $1.2M to be wired to a “new account.” The custodian processed it, and the RIA was sued for failing to verify instructions. Resolution required both a crime policy endorsement for social engineering and E&O coverage for client negligence allegations.

2

Board-Level Lawsuit (Private Equity Fund)

Limited partners alleged the fund’s general partners failed to disclose certain conflicts in a portfolio acquisition. The firm’s D&O policy covered defense and settlement, preserving not just balance sheet but reputations of individual executives.

3

Employee Fraud (Regional Lender)

A loan officer fabricated credit documents and pocketed borrower fees, leading to regulatory fines and client lawsuits. A Fidelity Bond responded, limiting the loss.

These scenarios show why coordination across E&O, D&O, Crime/Fidelity, and Cyber is critical. Coverage gaps aren’t theoretical; they’re where the most expensive losses occur.

Key Coverages Every Financial Services Business Should Consider

Financial service firms cannot rely on off-the-shelf business insurance. Your exposures demand specialized and tailored coverages that protect advice, leadership, transactions, and client trust. Below are the core coverages every firm should evaluate, with scenarios that illustrate why they matter.

Asset Managers Policy (AMP)

  • Definition: An AMP combines two critical protections, Errors & Omissions (E&O) and Directors & Officers (D&O), into one coordinated program. It is specifically designed for RIAs, broker-dealers, private equity firms, hedge funds, and other asset managers.
  • Why it matters: Asset managers face dual exposure, professional liability from client service issues and management liability from decisions made at the leadership level. A unified AMP streamlines coverage, avoids costly gaps, and ensures both the firm and its executives are protected under one comprehensive policy.
  • Example: A hedge fund faced simultaneous claims: investors alleged portfolio mismanagement (E&O) while regulators scrutinized board-level oversight failures (D&O). The AMP policy provided coordinated defense and settlement support, protecting both the firm and its leadership.

Errors & Omissions (E&O) / Professional Liability

  • Definition: Covers the firm and its professionals against claims of negligence, misrepresentation, or mistakes in delivering financial services.
  • Why it matters: A single trade error, compliance oversight, or suitability misstep can trigger costly lawsuits from clients, investors, or regulators, even if claims are groundless.
  • Example: An RIA misclassified a client’s risk profile, leading to outsized losses during a market swing. The E&O portion of the AMP covered defense costs and damages tied to suitability and fiduciary duty allegations.

Directors & Officers (D&O) Liability

  • Definition: Protects directors, officers, and firm leaders from claims of mismanagement, breach of fiduciary duty, or regulatory failures.
  • Why it matters: Without D&O protection, executives’ personal assets can be targeted by investors, regulators, or employees, putting leadership stability at risk.
  • Example: A mid-market private equity firm faced LP allegations of undisclosed conflicts in a portfolio acquisition. The D&O portion of the AMP funded a multi-million-dollar settlement, preserving both the firm’s balance sheet and its leaders’ reputations.

Bottom line

The AMP closes the gap between professional liability and management liability, ensuring the firm, its leadership, and its clients are all protected under one seamless policy.

Crime Insurance (Often called a Fidelity Bond)

  • Definition: Covers direct financial loss from employee dishonesty, forgery, fraud, and theft, including mandatory
  • Why it matters: Financial firms are prime targets for both internal fraud and external scams like funds-transfer fraud or business email compromise. Standard crime bonds often exclude these without endorsement.
  • Example: A loan officer created fake borrower profiles to skim fees. The firm’s Fidelity Bond responded, reimbursing direct financial loss. Without it, the firm would have absorbed the hit.

Cyber Liability (Including Funds-Transfer Fraud / BEC Business Email Compromise)

  • Definition: Protects against data breaches, ransomware, network intrusions, and financial fraud linked to cybercrime.
  • Why it matters: Financial firms are 4x more likely than other industries to be hit by BEC schemes. Many assume crime policies cover these losses, but without a social engineering or funds-transfer fraud rider, coverage is denied.
  • Example: A hedge fund CFO wired $800K to a spoofed vendor account. The firm’s cyber policy (with FTF coverage) reimbursed the funds and covered forensics and legal costs.

Employment Practices Liability (EPLI)

  • Definition: Covers lawsuits tied to wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment, or retaliation.
  • Why it matters: Financial firms often run lean, high-pressure teams. EPLI claims can arise quickly and damage both finances and reputation.
  • Example: A senior analyst alleged retaliation after flagging compliance concerns. The EPLI carrier defended and settled, preventing regulatory scrutiny from escalating.

Fiduciary Liability

  • Definition: Protects firms against claims tied to mismanagement of employee benefit plans (401(k), ESOPs, pensions).
  • Why it matters: Financial firms are natural fiduciaries, not only to clients but also to their own staff plans. ERISA claims can be steep and personal.
  • Example: A financial services firm failed to properly diversify its employee retirement plan. Fiduciary Liability covered defense costs and the plan’s financial shortfall.

Business Owners Policy

  • Definition: One policy to cover the property and general liability exposures common to any office or virtual office operations.
  • Why it matters: Even in finance, the basic risks of fire and slip and fall-type claims exist.
  • Example: A startup hedge fund leased office space in a shared office space rental, and the landlord required a certificate of insurance showing both property and liability coverages.
book a call with a Specialist About Your Coverage Options

How Much Does Financial Service Firm Insurance Cost?

Unlike standard business insurance, premiums for financial service firms hinge on exposures tied directly to your business model.

Cost Drivers

Insurers evaluate:

Compliance and audit team examining internal control documents, representing regulatory exposure and the need for specialized financial services insurance.
  • Revenue & Assets Under Management (AUM): Higher AUM or revenue = higher exposure to client claims.
  • Lines of Business: Broker-dealers, PE/VC, and fintech payment platforms face different risks than traditional lenders or RIAs.
  • Regulatory Complexity: Firms under SEC, FINRA, or state scrutiny may pay more due to heightened liability.
  • Claims History: Prior E&O, cyber, or employment claims can raise rates significantly.
  • Employee Count & Roles: Payroll affects workers’ comp and EPLI premiums, while high-volume advisors or traders elevate E&O exposure.
  • Cyber Hygiene: Firms with MFA, incident response plans, and vendor risk management often receive better pricing and terms.

Relative Factors

Some coverages carry disproportionate weight in the overall premium stack:

  • AMP / D&O and E&O: These typically represent the largest liability costs
  • Crime/Fidelity Bonds: Mandatory for broker-dealers; optional but strongly recommended for RIAs and PE/VC.
  • Cyber: Rates are heavily usage-driven. A fintech processing payments may spend more on cyber than on property and GL combined.

Common Coverage Gaps and Pitfalls

Even well-insured financial service firms often discover critical gaps only after a claim. These pitfalls are avoidable if you know what to look for.

Policy Exclusions Buyers Often Miss

  • Social Engineering Fraud: Standard crime or cyber policies may exclude or severely limit funds-transfer fraud unless a specific endorsement is added.
  • Insured vs. Insured (D&O): Many D&O policies exclude claims brought by one insured against another, problematic if investors or board members file suit.
  • Professional Services Exclusions: Generic liability or property policies often exclude losses tied to financial advice, trading, or fund management.
  • Regulatory Investigations: Defense costs for SEC or FINRA inquiries are sometimes limited or excluded, leaving firms on the hook for legal fees.
  • Third-Party Vendors: Cloud platforms, custodians, and fintech partners may have disclaimers that shift liability back to you, coverage doesn’t always follow
Schedule Your Gap Review Call

Why Standard Business Insurance Isn’t Enough

Generic GL Policies

These cover slip-and-fall injuries, not suitability claims or regulatory inquiries.

Cyber “Lite” Policies

Many entry-level cyber packages exclude BEC, funds-transfer fraud, or reputational harm, all top risks in finance.

Property Programs

Office leases may require specific BI or tenant-improvement coverage, but many firms only carry barebones property insurance.

Employee Litigation

Without EPLI, claims of harassment, discrimination, or retaliation fall outside general liability.

Now that you understand why generic business insurance falls short, the crucial question is: Does your current program leave you exposed? Find out by honestly answering these questions about your existing coverage:

Checklist for Financial service Firms

Instructor leading a financial planning workshop with young professionals, demonstrating how education and advisory roles intersect with financial services insurance protections.
  • Do we have a crime bond that explicitly covers social engineering fraud?
  • Does our D&O include coverage for regulatory investigations?
  • Are our vendor contracts mapped to our own coverage?
  • Does our cyber policy include funds-transfer fraud?
  • Are we double-checking exclusions that apply to RIAs, PE/VC firms, or broker-dealers specifically?

Broker’s Note: These details make the difference between a policy that just looks good on paper and one that actually responds when the claim hits.

Risk Management Beyond Insurance

Insurance is only part of the solution. Financial service firms that thrive long-term embed compliance discipline and operational resilience into their everyday practices.

→ Regulatory & Compliance Oversight

Regulatory bodies like the SEC, FINRA, and state regulators impose strict obligations around disclosure, suitability, and custody of client assets.

  • Challenge: Even unintentional missteps can trigger investigations.
  • Best Practice: Maintain a compliance calendar, document training, and conduct third-party audits annually.

→ Cybersecurity & Data Protection

Financial firms are prime targets for ransomware, BEC, and wire fraud. Regulators now expect frameworks like NIST CSF or ISO 27001.

  • Challenge: A single compromised email account can lead to seven-figure losses.
  • Best Practice: Enforce MFA, dual authorization for transfers, and annual penetration tests.

→ Vendor & Third-Party Risk

Custodians, fintech partners, and cloud providers extend your risk profile.

  • Challenge: Contracts often shift liability back to the firm.
  • Best Practice: Conduct vendor due diligence reviews, demand cyber liability certificates, and ensure indemnification clauses align with your own insurance.

→ Business Continuity & Disaster Recovery

Natural disasters, utility outages, and pandemics test operational resilience.

  • Challenge: Even “office-only” firms can’t afford downtime when clients can’t access funds.
  • Best Practice: Maintain tested BCP/DR plans, with redundancies in data centers and remote work protocols.

→ Talent & HR Risks

High-pressure environments lead to turnover, disputes, or whistleblower claims.

  • Challenge: Employment litigation can erode culture and reputation.
  • Best Practice: Invest in EPLI, whistleblower hotlines, and documented HR policies to handle disputes consistently.

Broker’s Perspective: In my experience, firms that treat insurance as the last line of defense, not the first, avoid the most costly surprises. Coverage fills the gaps, but compliance + cyber hygiene + vendor oversight are what keep regulators, investors, and clients confident.

How to Choose the Best Financial Service Firm Insurance Program

What to Look for in a Policy

When evaluating policies, don’t just compare premiums. Look deeper into:

Team discussing ESG governance standards during a meeting, highlighting how sustainability and governance risks connect to financial services insurance requirements.
  • Coverage for regulatory investigations in your AMP policy
  • Consider Dedicated Side-A (DIC) protection in your D&O coverage stack that protects individual directors and officers when the entity is bankrupt or barred from indemnification.
  • Whether coverage for independent contractors and advisors are included or excluded from the scope of coverage under the AMP.
  • Social Engineering and Funds Transfer Fraud Coverage – are your limits sufficient to your risks? Does coverage hinge on a mandated verification protocol?
  • Client Funds Coverage (AKA, Third Party Protection) – Does your crime policy extend to your client’s money and securities?

Benefits of Working With The Coyle Group

Financial service firms face a unique risk landscape, from regulatory investigations to investor lawsuits to cyber breaches. Most generalist brokers don’t fully understand these exposures or how to protect against them. That’s where The Coyle Group stands apart:

  • Specialized Market Access: We work directly with insurers who focus on financial institutions, giving you access to programs and underwriters most generalist brokers can’t reach.
  • Regulatory & Claims Advocacy: Our team has real-world experience helping firms navigate FINRA/SEC defense, investor litigation, and cyber forensic coordination. When the pressure is on, you’ll have a partner who knows the playbook.
  • Tailored Insurance Programs: Every firm’s regulatory footprint, investor structure, and cyber hygiene is different. We customize coverage to align with your business model so you’re never relying on “off-the-shelf” protection.
  • Benchmarking & Insight: We provide perspective on how peer firms are structuring limits, retentions, and coverage enhancements, giving you the data to make informed, confident decisions.

The Coyle Group gives you the confidence that your Financial Service Firm Insurance will actually respond when it matters most.

95+

Years of Family Legacy in Insurance

40+

Years Personal Experience

95%

Client Retention Rate

600+

Educational Videos

Schedule your strategy call

Questions to Ask Before You Buy

Before you commit to a policy, put these questions on the table:

  • Does the policy explicitly cover funds-transfer fraud and social engineering losses?
  • Are regulatory investigations included in defense costs, or only formal lawsuits?
  • What exclusions apply to Insured vs. Insured claims under D&O?
  • Does the cyber policy coordinate with crime coverage, or are there overlaps/gaps?
  • Has the broker placed policies for firms of my size and complexity in the last 12 months?

Broker’s Perspective: In my experience, the firms that make the smartest buys ask tough questions up front. Don’t just accept the binder; challenge your broker to explain why coverage is structured that way and how it will respond in a real claim.

Questions about Financial Services insurance?

Not all. Broker-dealers must carry a fidelity bond under FINRA Rule 4360, while RIAs and PE/VC firms often choose bonds voluntarily.
Even if not required, many investors and counterparties expect proof of coverage. A fidelity bond is often seen as a baseline safeguard against internal fraud.

E&O protects the firm for professional mistakes; D&O protects leaders for management decisions.
A client suing over bad advice is E&O. Investors alleging mismanagement is D&O. Most financial firms need both because exposures overlap but policies respond differently.

Usually not without an endorsement. Many base policies exclude these losses.
To be protected, firms need a social engineering or funds-transfer fraud rider, sometimes attached to crime, sometimes to cyber. Without it, coverage gaps are common.

More oversight often equals higher premiums.
Firms subject to SEC/FINRA examinations or those with past disciplinary actions may face higher D&O and E&O premiums, as insurers view them as higher-risk.

Yes. Even service-heavy firms lose revenue if offices or servers are down.
Downtime from fire, flood, or a utility outage can prevent client access, leading to lost income and reputational damage. BI coverage funds continuity during disruptions.

Costs vary widely; two similar firms can pay 2–3x different premiums.
Expanded: Key drivers include revenue, AUM, claims history, cyber posture, and regulatory oversight. The only way to know the true cost is through a tailored quote.

Social engineering fraud.
Many firms believe cyber automatically covers it—but most policies exclude wire-transfer fraud unless specifically endorsed. This is the most frequent and costly surprise.

Yes, if you have employees.
Employment practices lawsuits are common even in small, close-knit teams. Defense costs alone can exceed $100K, making EPLI an essential line regardless of firm size.

No. FDIC protects client deposits, and SIPC protects customer securities accounts. Neither protects the firm’s liabilities, compliance costs, or internal fraud exposure; that’s where business insurance comes in.

A specialized broker can coordinate the entire program. Splitting across multiple brokers creates overlap and gaps. A single advisor with financial services expertise ensures policies align and respond together in a claim.

Get the Right Insurance for Your Financial Services Business

You operate in one of the most highly regulated, scrutinized, and complex industries. The risks facing your firm, regulatory investigations, client lawsuits, insider fraud, or cybercrime, aren’t just theoretical. They happen every day, and when they do, the costs can be devastating.

With the right insurance program, you gain more than compliance; you gain confidence. You’ll know your policies are designed to respond to the specific exposures of financial service firms, not just generic office risks.

Your firm’s reputation, leadership, and balance sheet are too valuable to gamble on assumptions. Let’s make sure your insurance is as strong as your business.

This page was written by Gordon B. Coyle, CPCU, ARM, AMIM, PWCA, CEO of The Coyle Group, who brings over 40 years of experience advising financial services firms, investment managers, and professional organizations across the United States.

Here’s how to take the next step

Schedule Your Insurance Confidence Assessment

In our 30-minute call, you’ll discover:

  • Whether your current coverage matches your actual risks
  • If you’re getting fair value for what you’re paying
  • How your service experience compares to what’s possible
  • What questions you should be asking but probably aren’t
Schedule My Assessment Call

Not ready for a call?

Get Free Access to Our Gated Video:
“How to Finally Feel Confident in Your Coverage. “

And discover the exact system we use to help business owners eliminate hidden coverage gaps, stop overpaying, and finally feel confident in their protection.

What Peace of Mind Looks Like

Client Testimonials

  • I have discussed a variety of complex business opportunities with Gordon revolving around importing and exporting specialty goods globally and his knowledge and expertise has been invaluable.
    He’s been able to pinpoint key risk issues and provide solutions effectively and efficiently and highly recommend him.

    John Luce
    CEO/Founder, Costa Rica Coffee Trade Group USA

  • Gordon goes beyond just being our insurance broker, but is truly a trusted advisor in our opinion. We know we can tap into his knowledge as well as his rolodex to help our business grow and succeed.

    Michael Soltoff
    CEO, Eggersmann USA

  • Experts in their field, quick to respond to questions, trustworthy and reliable. Our business has been with the Coyle Group for over 40 years

    Alison Frankel
    Associate Artistic Director, Coupe Theatre Studio

  • The Coyle Group is on top of things! Their team is incredibly responsive and professional with a comprehensive approach to all your insurance needs. Highly recommend.

    Sari Jepsen
    Director of Finance, Scandic Builders

  • The Coyle Group is 1st class! Gordon and his team are knowledgeable, responsive, and attentive to detail. Gordon is that rare breed of professional who genuinely cares for his clients, and works hard to exceed their expectations. I highly recommend them.

    Jeff Carton
    Partner, Denlea & Carton, LLP

  • The Coyle Group took time to understand our business and our needs and has offered us customized solutions. The staff is friendly, responsive, and above all, they really know the industry.
    Highly recommend!

    Victoria Shire
    Vice President HERE to HERE

  • Our company has been with The Coyle Group over 10 years, and we couldn’t be more thoroughly satisfied. Their knowledge, expertise and professionalism are unmatched by anyone else we’ve worked with. Very responsive and helpful team!

    Jaclyn Di Meo
    Director of Finance, T.A. Sciences

  • Gordon and his team are a tremendous resource for our firm since its founding. Their deep expertise and quick turnaround time on critical issues have been exemplary.

    Catherine Ryan
    VP of Operations, Jaguar Growth Partners

Want to know more?

See related blogs